Close filter
CFO & Audit Chair

Measuring CFO Strengths and Weaknesses

Explore the critical competencies and areas for growth impacting a CFO’s effectiveness in our comprehensive guide on evaluating CFO strengths and weaknesses.

Understanding the attributes that lead to a strong financial leader is crucial not only during the hiring process but also throughout their tenure to ensure alignment with the organization’s strategic goals. This article explores the vital competencies and potential areas for improvement that influence a CFO’s effectiveness in steering complex financial landscapes and impacting business operations. 

We’ll examine the key traits that define successful CFOs and propose strategies to enhance their capabilities to meet the evolving demands of their role.

Key Strengths of a Successful CFO

Identifying the strengths of a sitting – or potential – CFO is key in understanding their capacity to meet and exceed the expanding demands of their role. The following strengths will highlight their competence while also revealing their potential to propel the company forward:

  1. Strategic foresight: Proficient CFOs excel in mapping out long-term financial strategies that align with broader business goals. They can anticipate market trends and prepare the company for future challenges and opportunities.
  2. Leadership and influence: Effective CFOs are adept at building and leading teams, motivating staff, and fostering an environment of collaboration and respect across all levels of the organization.
  3. Financial expertise: At their core, CFOs must exhibit unmatched financial acumen, from complex financial modeling to comprehensive budget management and reporting.
  4. Adaptability and Innovation: The best CFOs are those who adapt quickly to changes and use innovative approaches to solve financial challenges, ensuring the company remains resilient and competitive.

Looking for more strengths? Check out our guide to CFO Competencies, Skills, and Potential here

 

CFOs today are more than financial stewards – they are strategic partners who must blend analytical prowess with forward-thinking leadership,” said consultant Rachel Williams, who is also a former CFO. “At Egon Zehnder, we recognize the evolving demands on CFOs and support them through tailored assessment and development strategies. This ensures they are not only equipped to manage financial complexities but are also prepared to drive strategic initiatives that align with long-term business goals.

Rachel Williams, CFO and Supply Chain Executive Consultant

 

Common Weaknesses of CFOs to Consider

Even the most skilled CFOs can have areas of weakness that may impact their effectiveness. Identifying the following areas is crucial for continuous improvement and strategic development at every stage in their CFO tenure:

  1. Resistance to change: Some CFOs may struggle with the fast pace of change in business and technology. Organizations can support these executives by providing resources for continuous learning and development, encouraging them to stay ahead of industry trends.
  2. Communication gaps: A CFO's inability to communicate complex financial data in an understandable way can lead to strategic misalignments. Regular training in communication skills and providing clear channels for information flow can mitigate this.
  3. Technological reluctance: CFOs who are slow to adopt new technologies can hinder the efficiency of financial operations. Promoting a culture of technological innovation and offering specific training in new financial tools can help bridge this gap.

Ongoing Evaluation and Role Enhancement for CFOs

Once a CFO is hired, their evaluation and development become integral to maintaining the agility and responsiveness of the finance function within their new company. Continuous performance evaluation is essential to ensure that CFOs not only meet the current needs of the organization but also adapt to its evolving demands and opportunities. Regular assessments, such as 360-degree feedback, provide comprehensive insights from various stakeholders, encompassing peers, subordinates, and supervisors, offering a rounded view of the CFO's impact and areas for improvement.

Goal tracking is another crucial method that aligns the CFO's objectives with the strategic goals of the organization. By setting clear, measurable targets, companies can monitor progress and provide timely feedback, facilitating a dynamic adjustment of strategies and priorities in real-time. 

Leveraging external CFO services for periodic audits can offer an unbiased review of the CFO’s role and effectiveness, ensuring that financial controls and strategies remain robust and forward-thinking. These audits help identify not just compliance with financial regulations but also opportunities for strategic enhancement, keeping the CFO’s role in perfect sync with the broader business objectives.

 

CFOs are not just meeting but embracing new demands beyond their core functions, with 8 in 10 experiencing significant growth in their roles over the past five years. They are going beyond their technical expertise, truly evolving into indispensable superheroes. As one CFO put it, ‘CFO is not a finance role. It is a strategic business role whose mandate is finance. CFOs should continue to be seen as a full partner to revenue-generating business lines and used as a counterpoint to ensure the right level of challenge, investment, and productivity is achieved to maximize long-term business strategy and financial outcomes.

Egon Zehnder’s The Super CFO Report

 

How to Identify Potential Amidst a Sea of CFO Candidates

The process of selecting the right CFO is a thorough and comprehensive one, involving a meticulous evaluation of both the tangible and intangible attributes of potential candidates. This hiring process includes conducting detailed interviews and assessments where behavioral interview techniques and scenario-based questions are employed to determine how well candidates can navigate complex financial scenarios and strategic challenges. 

Additionally, the assessment process extends beyond hiring, encompassing ongoing performance evaluations. These evaluations are structured and regularly updated to stay aligned with evolving business needs, ensuring the CFO's role continuously adapts and responds to the company's requirements. 

This proactive approach in both hiring and ongoing evaluation is crucial to maintaining effective financial leadership within the organization.

The Value of Leveraging External Expertise

As the responsibilities of your CFO grow, the importance of a thorough evaluation and continuous development of their work cannot be overstated. 

This is where the expertise of external consultants becomes invaluable.

External CFO consultants provide a critical service in the evaluation and development process. They bring objective insights and specialized knowledge that may not be available internally. These experts are equipped with tools and frameworks that help identify both the overt strengths and the subtle areas for improvement that might not be immediately apparent. 

Plus, by offering an external perspective, these consultants can bypass internal biases and politics, ensuring that the evaluation is both comprehensive and impartial. 

But the role of external consultants does not end with evaluation. A consultant will support CFOs throughout their career lifecycle – from identifying potential CFO candidates to enhancing their capabilities to meet current and future challenges. This ongoing support ensures that CFOs are not only fit for the role today but are also evolving with the role's demands, thereby securing the organization’s financial and strategic future.

Reach Out to Egon Zehnder for Help with Evaluating CFO Strengths and Weaknesses 

Incorporating external expertise into the CFO evaluation and development process is crucial for organizations aiming to thrive in a complex business environment. It reinforces the need for continuous leadership development and helps maintain the sharp edge of financial governance and strategic innovation.

At Egon Zehnder, many of our specialized consultants are former C-suite and financial leaders themselves – so they don’t just talk when it comes to evaluating your CFO potential. They understand what needs to be done inside and out to ensure your company has the right person at the helm. 

For organizations looking to harness the full potential of their financial leadership, or for those in need of expert guidance in evaluating and developing their soon-to-be CFO, explore Egon Zehnder's executive search and leadership assessment functions. If we seem like the right fit for your needs, reach out to leverage our deep expertise in CFO recruitment and development.  Remember – we’re here to help you ensure your leadership strategy is robust and forward-thinking.

Topics Related to this Article

Changing language
Close icon

You are switching to an alternate language version of the Egon Zehnder website. The page you are currently on does not have a translated version. If you continue, you will be taken to the alternate language home page.

Continue to the website

Back to top