Imagine this job offer withdrawal scenario…

After investing in a lengthy executive search process, your top candidate accepts the executive job offer, and you are confident in their ability to drive growth and navigate pressing challenges. It seems like a perfect match for both sides–however, the candidate unexpectedly withdraws their acceptance.

Unfortunately, this scenario is not uncommon and yields significant implications for the candidate, their current company, and the company who hired them. Understanding the reasons behind the withdrawal is crucial, and so is considering the consequences for all parties involved.

A Candidate’s Job Offer Withdrawal: A Real Story

We recently faced the job offer withdrawal situation where a top candidate accepted an offer to work for a competitor after months of negotiations, over 10 interviews with senior executives, including shareholders, and legal fees to ensure the contract was in order. However, when he informed his current boss and shareholders, they convinced him to stay, offering a compensation package twice as big as that of our client. 

This forced us to restart our candidate search, now under a tight deadline, with a frustrated client, and the subliminal desire to find not just another candidate, but a clone of the one we lost.

Unexpectedly, after the initial surprise and frustration, I felt relief. 

If a candidate we evaluated and recommended makes such a decision, we clearly missed something critical about their decision-making process or personality. It's better this happens now, before they join the new company.

Top Reasons Why Job Offer Withdrawal May Occur After Accepting

There are several reasons for job offer withdrawal from a top candidate – and all of them are valid but put the hiring team in a tough position. Some common scenarios I see in my work include:

Reason #1. Personal Life or Family Changes

Typically, these decision-making processes are lengthy and involve the candidate’s family. During this period, unexpected personal or family changes, such as serious illness or the need for family members to adjust to a new city, can influence the decision to stay in the current position, where an established support network may already exist.

Reason #2. Company Instability

Information about financial or organizational instability at the new company may emerge during the transition period, prompting the candidate to reconsider. In fact, this has happened to us in the past, with the disclosure of poor results that nearly led the company to bankruptcy. Fortunately for the candidate who had accepted, her departure had not yet been announced from her current company.

Reason #3. More Attractive Offers Arise

Additionally, more attractive offers may arise, leading the candidate to choose an opportunity that better aligns with their career goals. For example, a few years ago, we hired a Chief Financial Officer set to start on a Monday at the client’s overseas headquarters. When that day came, the client called to ask if there were any issues. When I spoke with the candidate, he explained: after returning to his home country on Friday, and informing the other company he was considering, they made him an irresistible offer. He started with them on that same Monday but didn't inform us.

The Risks of Withdrawing from a Job Offer

When a candidate approaches the job offer withdrawal in a non-transparent way, this individual will be seen as unreliable, harming their reputation and damaging important industry relationships. They are less likely to be considered for other opportunities as well. Candidates should be transparent and manage relationships with care and integrity throughout any recruitment process they participate in.

At the same time, this candidate risks their current role. We’ve seen candidates accept external offers but then be convinced by their current company to stay, only to be terminated six-to-18 months. The tension from this situation can grow over time on both sides. The candidate might realize they didn’t want to stay but were convinced for financial reasons, while the employer may become suspicious of their loyalty and commitment—eventually deciding to let them go and hire someone they believe is more trustworthy and genuinely willing to tackle current challenges.

The implications also affect the client who has recruited the new candidate. Recruiting executives is a time-consuming and costly process. When the chosen candidate backs out at the last minute, the company must restart the entire process, leading to increased costs and lost time. Moreover, if word gets out, the team expecting the new hire can feel demotivated and uncertain, potentially affecting their productivity. If the withdrawal becomes public, the company may be seen as unstable and unattractive, making it harder to attract talent in the future.

11 Tips to Mitigate the Risks of Job Offer Withdrawal

When a candidate withdraws from a job offer after accepting it, negative consequences follow suit. To mitigate the risks, it is important that companies understand the potential motivations behind these decisions and implementing strategies to mitigate them. 

Tip #1. Ensure Clear Role Understanding

• Clearly communicate job responsibilities, expectations, and company culture to the candidate.
• Use detailed job descriptions and realistic job previews to avoid misunderstandings.

Tip #2. Open and Honest Communication

• Maintain transparent communication throughout the recruitment process.
• Regularly check in with the candidate to address any concerns or questions they might have.

Tip #3. Thorough Vetting Process

•  Conduct comprehensive interviews that explore the candidate's motivations, career goals, and fit with the company culture.
• Implement robust reference checks to verify the candidate’s background and suitability.

Tip #4. Clear Contractual Agreements

• Establish contracts with specific clauses on withdrawals, including potential penalties.
• Outline clear terms and conditions regarding resignation or withdrawal to protect the organization.

Tip #5. Support During Transition

• Provide assistance with relocation to help the new executive settle in smoothly.
• Offer cultural integration support to help the candidate adjust to the new environment.

Tip #6. Engage Multiple Team Members

• Involve different team members in the interview process to gather diverse perspectives on the candidate's fit.
• Ensure alignment among the hiring team regarding the candidate's suitability.

Tip #7. Regular Follow-Ups

•  Schedule regular follow-ups with the candidate after the offer is extended but before they start, to maintain engagement and address any potential issues.
• Use these follow-ups to reaffirm their decision and commitment.

Tip #8. Onboarding Support

• Develop a comprehensive onboarding program to support the candidate’s transition into the company.
• Assign a mentor to help the new hire navigate the organizational landscape.

Tip #9. Offer Competitive Compensation and Benefits

• Ensure that the compensation package is competitive and reflects the candidate’s value and market standards.
• Highlight benefits that support work-life balance and professional growth.

Tip #10. Create a Positive Candidate Experience

• Ensure a smooth and respectful hiring process that leaves a positive impression on the candidate.
• Address any issues promptly and professionally to build trust and rapport.

Tip #11. Flexibility and Negotiation

• Be open to negotiating terms that are important to the candidate, such as flexible working arrangements or additional support for family relocation.
• Show willingness to accommodate reasonable requests to enhance the candidate's commitment.

By implementing these strategies, organizations can reduce the risk of job withdrawals and ensure that they extend offers to the right candidates, fostering a more stable and committed workforce.

Working with a Partner Who Understands Executive Search Complexities

An Executive Search and Leadership Advisory Firm, such as Egon Zehnder, can serve as an indispensable guide in helping companies to successfully hire executives in a challenging and competitive talent landscape. Our focus is on understanding your industry, your company, your team, and your specific situation, and each search engagement is customized to your objectives and needs. We help you benchmark and develop potential internal candidates and we can connect you with the best external candidates in circumstances that often require a new perspective, such as the creation of a new position, the replacement of an incumbent or large-scale transformational changes.

Please click here to learn more about our Executive Search services.